Venerated words.
There may be an epidemic in our minds and one too in our souls but even if so these would not be the same. Literalism muddles frames of meaning, prejudicing understanding and misdirecting choice. Words are not the things they represent. The map is not the territory.

λ    

literal error

Words are dumb, assumptions confounding logic and feelings; on the other side of their mirror it may appear that I am mad.

language and meaning

this edit: 9 Dec 2024, written: 9 May 2018.
1.   Ineffability.

No matter who speaks the words of Man they are not the Words of God. Tao called Tao is not Tao; the map is not the territory. Words are not the things they represent.

Everywhere, the belief that words can enchain the ineffable is exploited to justify the exercise of power. Whether in churches, temples, universities, or mosques, literalism and fundamentalism coextend. Bt whatever chemistry life first stepped through, extending beyond any boundary of conception or death, distinct from the temporal struggles of biology matters of meaning remain.

Abandoning reason science gazes into the abyss, a suicidal self-belief at war with fundamentalists.
2.  Belief.

Annexing the dreams of a heaven on Earth, SCRIPTURE cloaked the universe. Literal interpretations became grammar and laws, and nations were drawn around our feudal states — not through enlightenment but by force. War crippled their hopes and in the ruin scientism, a new faith, has taken root.. Science however has no place for faith, it is simple and disengaged. Neither human nor divine, faith only corrupts it.

A crow lands in a tree, a piece of bread in her beak, but that branch slopes, unsuited she tries another, but that's too narrow, so placing her prize on a sprig she adjusts her place and grasps it —a lesson learned.
3.  Complimentarity.

Literal and metaphorical frames of reference express concrete and abstract descriptions — the body, the mind, and the soul, for instance. A statement is simply a perspective on the whole; incomplete and partial. Words and concepts are not innately twinned, opposites are not necessarily contradictory or conflicting — the mind does not exist yet obviously it does, colour does not exist and yet obviously it does.

It is inevitable that different frames of reference arise from the separation intrinsic to individual awareness. For meaning to be shared common ones are negotiated; however, they are routinely muddled to establish category-mistakes as by fragmenting meaning these bypass reason, appealing to emotions to validate rhetoric and establish beliefs that factionalize opinion and neutralize debate.

Three million unemployed; three million immigrants. There is no equality here.
4.  Literalism.

Words are just noise or marks on a page, their only meaning that which we give them. Personal and ambiguous, they are labels for those things in our perception that we found important in the frame of expression which imprinted our ontogeny. As 'native' phrasal languages are displaces by literacy, they become more powerful, both in societies and in individuals. Increasingly seen as the things they represent, their storylines guide us while those less literate are rendered dumb and powerless, disorientated as scriptures replace wisdom.

Conflating words and meaning, losing sight of where we are, questions and answers turn into endless vicious circles.
5.  Expression.

Communication is primitive and fundamental. In the primordial soup some wriggling thing unknowingly spoke, and in some manner its environment replied. Each being, simply by engaging with its environment, communicates with others, however unconnected they might seem, and irrespective of whether they understand what may be meant or not each in their way responds. In the beginning was the word, just not one we recognize.

Life recognizes usefulness in significance and signs; its presence breeds reactions, and environments are born.
6.  Biophysical.

Life needs awareness to make the choices needed to survive — how else could it be; only this essential singularity sets its BEINGS apart.

BEINGS, bootstrapped from inherited code, use prior experience to assess their current sensations, converting whatever they can recognize into the measurements of significance that inform their actions.

Just as every PSYCHOLOGICAL construct requires a BIOPHYSICAL correlate in order to exist, every BIOPHYSICAL construct requires a PSYCHOLOGICAL correlate in order to survive. PSYCHOLOGY in reality is meta-biophysical.


If creationist teleologies are set-aside and it is accepted that descriptions of the ineffable are unavoidably metaphorical, then unencumbered by anthropocentric concepts of the soul, BEINGS can be defined as 'vehicles' of life', and life inferred recursively. The term BIOPHYSICAL here is then used to refer to their actuality.



Body and mind, the wax and its form — only in imagination can these be divided.

on being heard

With a foreign tongue I can barely speak here, but even in silence language is inescapable. This is not madness. The brain, reflecting on the information the senses provide, asleep or awake anticipates a future space, integrating experience into an internal model, and testing this through thought and conversation.
open quotation markIt is not necessary to ask whether soul and body are one, just as it is not necessary to ask whether the wax and its shape are one, nor generally whether the matter of each thing and that of which it is the matter are one. For even if one and being are spoken of in several ways, what is properly so spoken of is the actuality.    Aristotle, 350 BC
From De Anima, ii 1, 412b6-9: published by MIT Classics.

spirit and soul


open quotation markAccording to Barnhart and OED (1989), the earliest use of the word [spirit] in English mainly is from passages in the Vulgate, where the Latin word [SPIRITUS] translates Greek PNEUMA and Hebrew RUAH. A distinction between soul and spirit (as "seat of emotions") became current in Christian terminology (such as Greek PSYKHE and PNEUMA, Latin ANIMA and SPIRITUS) but "is without significance for earlier periods" [Buck]. Latin SPIRITUS, usually in classical Latin "breath," replaced ANIMUS in the sense "spirit" in the imperial period and appears in Christian writings as the usual equivalent of Greek PNEUMA.    from: Etymonline, spirit - retrieved 17 June 2024.

It then seems reasonable that the pre-Christian concept of an animating force (a breath or spirit) be translated as the meta-biological construct, biosemiosis.spirit



It is as correct, as it is incorrect, to say that hormones create love, as to say that love creates hormones.

complementarity


Niels Bohr, who received the Nobel Prize for his foundational work on Quantum theory, conceived the Principle of Complementarity —that singular items could at the same time possess apparently mutually exclusive properties— after realizing that light behaved like both waves and particles. His motto became: "Contraria non contradictoria sed complementa sunt", meaning: contradictions are not contradictory but complimentary.

On words and meaning, he wrote:

open quotation mark What is it that we human beings ultimately depend on? We depend on our words. We are suspended in language. Our task is to communicate experience and ideas to others.
Niels Bohr, in Bulletin of the Atomic Scientists, 1963.


phrasal language


30 Apr 2024. edit: 7 Oct 2023.

Languages we use to communicate with are not acquired through learning letters and grammars. Individual expression is acquired through the repeated use of increasingly lengthy and complex word-blocks —of words then phrases, sentences, and paragraphs— learning the concepts and laws of a language through real, and virtual, social interaction.

While 'primitive' peoples even today are still able to express themselves routinely and seamlessly in more than half a dozen languages, with the establishment of nation states it has become normal for the majority of a people to speak only the official language of the state that they reside in.




As the translators of the Tao Te Ching [1] explain — referring to their translation of the six, symmetric characters it opens with as "Tao called Tao is not Tao" — translations are necessarily approximations, incapable of fully reflecting each others' unique heritage and nuancing. Korzybski[2] specifies the fundamental issue — "The map is not the territory." "Words are not the things they represent." — When translations from one terrestrial language to another are unavoidably approximate, and language ambiguous, how much more so is any translation of a deity's 'language' — the utterances of infants more precisely approximate those of adults than the words of Man do the Words of God.

see: 1. Tao Te Ching, Lao Tzu, 300 BCE, translated by Stephen Aldiss and Stanley Lombardo, 1993, Hackett Publishing Company, Inc. 2. 'A Non-Aristotlean System and its Necessity for Rigour in Mathematics and Physics' Alfred Korzybski, 1931.


Fundamentalism here carries a belief-neutral definition: the rigid adherence to a point of view characterized by fundamental principles, and an aggressive intolerance of other views.



words and maps



In the paper 'A Non-Aristotlean System and its Necessity for Rigour in Mathematics and Physics', presented to the American Mathematical Society in 1931, Alfred Korzybski made two observations: 'A map is not the territory', and 'Words are not the things they represent' (here highlighted in bold; italic emphases by the author).

quote left ... A) A map may have a structure similar or dissimilar to the structure of the territory. B) Two similar structures have similar 'logical' characteristics. Thus, if in a correct map, Dresden is given as between Paris and Warsaw, a similar relationship is found in the actual territory C) A map is not the territory. D) An ideal map would contain the map of the map, the map of the map of the map., endlessly. ... We may call it self-reflexiveness. Languages share with the map the above four characteristics. A) Languages have structure, thus we may have languages of elementalist structure such as 'space' and 'time', 'observer' and 'observed', 'body' and 'soul', 'senses' and 'mind', 'intellect' and 'emotions', 'thinking' and 'feeling', 'thought' and 'intuition'., which allow verbal division or separation. Or we may have languages of a non-elementalist structure such as 'space-time', the new quantum languages, 'time binding', 'different order abstractions', 'semantic reactions'., which do not involve verbal division or separation.; also mathematical languages of 'order', 'relation', 'structure', 'function', 'variable', 'invariant', 'difference', 'addition', 'division'., which apply to 'senses' and 'mind', that is, can be 'seen' and 'thought of',. B) If we use languages of a structure non-similar to the world and our nervous system, our verbal predictions are not verified empirically, we cannot be 'rational' or adjusted,. ... ,. C) Words are not the things they represent. D) Language also has self-reflexive characteristics. We use language to speak about language, which fact introduces serious verbal and semantic difficulties solved by the theory of multiordinality. ...     Alfred Korzybski, 1931.




inclosure


edit: 9 Nov 2024, written: 25 Sep 2021.

During the Middle Ages — the 5th to 12th centuries — and later, the Latin word feudum was used to refer to freehold property. Only in the 17th century was the term feudalism coined by historians to create an historical narrative for European nation states.

Since the Middle Ages, local lords had expanded the territories subject to them, and intensified their control over the peoples living there. In the 17th century the Inclosure Acts began, creating property rights over land that previously had been held in common. In England and Wales, between 1604 and 1914 over 5,200 such Acts enclosed around 28,000 km2 of open fields and common land. Tenants and their descendants were evicted. Displaced from the countryside they were forced to look for employment in cities and factories. The poem: The Goose and the Common, by an unknown 18th century writer, protests the injustice:

They hang the man and flog the woman Who steals the goose from off the common Yet let the greater villain loose That steals the common from the goose. The law demands that we atone When we take things we do not own But leaves the lords and ladies fine Who take things that are yours and mine. The poor and wretched don't escape If they conspire the law to break This must be so but they endure Those who conspire to make the law. The law locks up the man or woman Who steals the goose from off the common And geese will still a common lack Till they go and steal it back.

For the history of the Inclosure Acts in the UK see e.g: Enclosing the Land, published on the British Government website, and: Inclosure Acts, on Wikipedia.




open quotation markThe whole of science is nothing more than a refinement of everyday thinking..    Albert Einstein.
from: Physics and Reality, published in the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Vol. 221, Issue 3, March 1936, pp. 349-382.

The total land area of England and Wales is approximately 151,000 km2. The Inclosed land represented nearly 20% of the total land area of the combined countries.



open quotation markHe who fights with monsters should see to it that he himself does not become a monster. And if you gaze long into an abyss, the abyss also gazes into you.    Friedrich Nietzsche, 1886,
Aphorism 146, in 'Beyond Good and Evil: Prelude to a Philosophy of the Future', translated by Helen Zimmern. C.G. Naumann, Leipzig, 1886.

Meaning is a personal perception of expression encoded by the reference-frame of ontogeny. For choice not to be misguided the different reference-frames that inevitably arise must then be recognized and reconciled. Locusts are successful, but they are unable to escape growing from peaceful co-existance as individuals to the cannibalistic war of a swarm.

Whether or not there is free-will, we can only choose.

reconciling difference


13 April 2023, written: 17 March 2023.

Societies are founded on the reconciliation of differences. Winning the peace is a contradiction in terms; war just increases social entropy, turning back the clock, extinguishing evolved social knowledge, and regressing society to a more primitive state.

Wars are colonial endeavours to replace social forms; those fought by colonialists to establish themselves in other countries, for instance, or by established interests to exploit industrialization or virtualization. Destruction is their common goal.

Leaving the majority stripped of rights, wars recycle their assets, converting them into investments for those with power. The advice, attributed to Baron Rothschild, "When there's blood on the streets, buy property", only applies to those with the power to retain their assets.




virtuality refers to abstractions of actuality that pre-process experience.




We recognize what we see, this is our perception, inherited then learnt from experience. We see what we expect to see, accordingly constructing and integrating the data that our eyes, and other senses are capable of recording.



The term being, is used here for all forms of life, whether multicellular (e.g. humans, ants, plants, etc); unicellular (e.g. bacteria, archaea, and some algae), or both (e.g. slime molds), and to other metasystems (e.g. jellyfish, and societies, of ants, humans, deer etc.




Bioemiosis proceeds through recognition — through current sense-data that a being perceives then being recognized by it; as being the same as, or belonging to the same class as, something the being has sensed or perceived before. This then is a recursive process, its first iteration (or 'base case') generating meaning by matching current sense-data and perceptions to those that have previously been recognized, recorded, embodied, and inherited.

Here embodiment refers to the biophysical expression of semiosis and to the semiosis that biophysical expression represents; and embodied cognition is then simply a description of biosemiosis.


NB. The definitions used here may vary considerably, both in degree and specificity, to those used elsewhere; nonetheless, they also overlap with them considerably.


A metatransition is a metasystem transition to EITHER a more complex OR a simpler structure, ultimately leading to a transitory OR a permanent evolutionary transition in individuality.

NB. The labels, 'more complex', 'simpler', 'transitory' and 'permanent', here refer to relative positions on subjectively defined axis, not to any objective measurements.



Here, refers to the general, rather than a restricted, controlling or organizational system which maintains the homeostasis necessary for the functioning of a system and its subsystems.




Please see: here for a summary and references.



The prefix "meta-" is used here as it is in the term "metalanguage" — a system of symbols or signs used to describe another system of symbol or signs — to refer to the metasemiotic expression of biosemiosis.

psychosomatic


19 Nov. 2024, edit 7 Mar. 2025.

If it is accepted as unavoidable that descriptions of the ineffable are metaphorical, and creationist teleologies are set-aside, unencumbered by anthropocentric concepts of the soul, BEINGS can be defined simply as 'vehicles' of life, and life inferred recursively. The term BIOPHYSICAL is then used here to refer to their actuality.

BEINGS are BIOPHYSICAL, their abstract, psychological attributes, particularly in humans, referred to as awareness, consciousness, EGO, and mind. In much the same way as attributes such as colour, they are EXPRESSIONS — colour relating to both inanimate and animate NOUMENA; and consciousness etc, only to animate NOUMENA.

Wellness and illness are then PSYCHOSOMATIC, existing in a 'space' that is both BIOPHYSICAL and PSYCHOLOGICAL. Their development therefore is a function of BIOPHYSICAL, PSYCHOLOGICAL, and environmental factors, that are impacted upon by social support and care, and medical and psychological interventions. However, despite the fact that, for instance, cancer research has substantiated this, modern societies and organizations still ridicule it.



© robin greaves, 2018-2025.
quoteleftI'd like people to reconceptualize cancer as a biological event that triggers stress responses affecting how the disease progresses... Managing those stress responses by adopting healthy eating and exercise habits, getting a good night's sleep, and finding good emotional and social support, should be regarded as much a part of cancer treatment as chemotherapy or radiation.
David Spiegel, MD, Stanford University Medical Center. Stanford research builds link between sleep, cancer progression, Stanford Medicine News Center, 2003.


© robin greaves, 2018-2025.

family inheritance


a recursive definition 10 Mat 2025.

Life is the state of being. Being is the condition of BEINGS.

A BEING is a descendant of a BEING.

I am a BEING.



© robin greaves, 2018-2025.

It is as correct or incorrect to say that hormones create love as it is to say that love creates hormones. Love is not definable in the way that hormones are; they are terms in different frames of reference.


Noumenon, is a Greek word meaning "that which is perceived". It is used here in that simple sense. Although Kant was the first person to use the term as a loanword, it is not used here to refer to his philosophy generally.

Kant adopted the Greek word, noumenon, to refer to the thing-in-itself so that this underlying reality might more readily be distinguished in discussion from the recognition by an observer of it that then renders it as a sign. However, whereas Kant referred to this recognition as perception — and to the perception of the thing-in-itself as a phenomenon — here the term perception is used simply to refer to a specific step in the process of biosemiosis.



A language is a system of arbitrary signals used to communicate information. To communicate, is to convey information through a system of arbitrary signals. Semantic means of or relating to meaning. Meaning refers to the sense or reference of an expression. To recognize, is to know something as the same as, or belonging to the same class as, something known before.


The definitions above, apart from those for meaning and recognize which are after those in the Collins English Dictionary, are after those in the American Heritage Dictionary of the English Language.



quoteleftHydrozoa show great diversity of lifestyle; some species maintain the polyp form for their entire life and do not form medusae at all Polyps of some species propagate vegetatively, forming colonies.. polymorphism occurs in colonies of some species of hydrozoans and anthozoans, the polyps being specialized for functions such as feeding, defense, and sexual reproduction.



Ruppert, Edward E.; Fox, Richard, S.; Barnes, Robert D. (2004). Invertebrate Zoology, 7th edition. Cengage Learning. pp. 148-174; cited in Jellyfish, Taxonomy (list item: Staurozoa), Wikipedia..



Fautin, Daphne G. and Sandra L. Romano. 1997. Cnidaria. Sea anemones, corals, jellyfish, sea pens, hydra. Version 24 April 1997. http://tolweb.org/Cnidaria/2461/1997.04.24 in The Tree of Life Web Project, http://tolweb.org/.



Anthropocentrism is the narcissistic belief that the human species is the central fact and final aim of a universe that should therefore be understood in terms of human experience, needs, and values.




Ribeiroia in herons, fungi on beetles, or the staph in our guts, win minds and hearts over to serve other gods. Shut outside our doors of reason, flocking crows and horses, otters, gorillas, chimps and geese, play follow the leader. What makes us special. Or more so than dogs.


scientism


open quotation markThe whole of science is nothing more than a refinement of everyday thinking.    Albert Einstein.

Science is an elementary practice. Scientism is a belief. Eugenics and the Holocaust are among the brutal consequences and stark reminders of not recognizing this distinction..




from: Physics and Reality, published in the Journal of the Franklin Institute, Vol. 221, Issue 3, March 1936, pp. 349-382.


from: "The Great Chain of Semiosis, Investigating the Steps in the Evolution of Semiotic Competence." p.8, Jesper Hoffmeyer & Frederik Stjernfelt, September 2015, Biosemiotics 9(1) DOI:10.1007/s12304-015-9247-y (Emphasis added).


foreword
comment
consultancy

comment: *

subject: *

name: *

email: